redyelmv.gif (12119 bytes)  Home Laws Advice Fitness SiteMap Links Set Pieces Discuss Search corshamref.org.uk   

Article 6 Page

Take me back to the Articles Home page

Please let me have your articles for publications on this Web site.

1. FIFA Confederations Cup 2003
By Jim Ouliaris FIFA Assistant Referee Australian Team

2. Relax. It is OK to hate Referees after all. They really are superior!
Report compiled by Julian Carosi

3. Collars and Cuffs (and all things white!) By Julian Carosi

4. Ref. is given his cards by the Boss! By Julian Carosi

5. Reffing in Rockhampton By Allan Barber

6. Refereeing in Zimbabwe by Hilton Mukuwiri


1. FIFA Confederations Cup

France 18th – 29th of June 2003

By Jim Ouliaris
FIFA Assistant Referee
Australian Team

 

Jim Ouliaris
Jim Ouliaris

USA vs. Cameroon 23/06/03
USA vs. Cameroon – 23/06/03

USA vs. Cameroon  23/06/03
USA vs. Cameroon – 23/06/03

What an introduction?

To live, eat, work and breath FIFA throughout a tournament is an amazing experience that few of us get the opportunity to live! This is just a brief outline of some of the experiences I was fortunate enough to encounter. As soon as we arrived Saturday 14/06/03 at 9.00am we were met by a liaison officer at Charles de Gaulle Airport Paris. We were taken to the Sofitel where we were given an accreditation badge (this gave us access to all playing venues and VIP areas), our KIT for the tournament, which contained all uniforms, equipment, and our suit for formal occasions and functions. When we were finished with all the formalities, we were then registered into the hotel were we could rest and freshen up before meeting all the other referees appointed to the tournament.

Education / Seminar

The pre-tournament seminar and instruction was amazing. The tables were set up in a large C shape with a huge video screen in the centre. Our names were randomly placed on the tables so that we could mix with other referees. We had a number of targets to implement and uphold at this tournament. These were:

Training

Training took part every day once the tournament started. Our training combined many elements and training programs and would usually last for 1 to 1 ½ hours.

Many of these sessions combined exercises with soccer ball as they assisted in concentration. Your ball had to be passed onto another colleague whiles running. It was also a good opportunity to meet and work with other referees from many countries around the world in a fun and relaxed atmosphere.

Technical Reviews / Improvement

After each day all the referees were required to attend the daily technical review meeting at 3pm sharp (no late comers were tolerated). At these sessions the games from the previous day were dissected and analysed for all to learn from. The analysis took place in the form of a video review whereby all cards, offsides, critical incidents such as goals, positioning, serious fouls and any interesting areas of play were put together and discussed by the technical advisors. Referees and assistant referees were asked their opinions as to why they did what was seen on the screen.

One incident I remember clearly related to a decision (or non decision) that occurred in the Japan vs. France game. I kept my flag down when the Japanese team and the crowd yelled for an off-side. It was one of those incidents where I was in doubt about the players position so I kept my flag down. I must say I was a little nervous the next day, as I knew this incident would be brought up on the video review. It lead to a goal to which France won the game 2 : 1 against Japan. When I saw my decision, of the player running into an on-side position, the technical advisors broke down my decision frame by frame and showed me that at the moment the ball was kicked the attacking player was inline with the defenders, but as it travelled into the air the attacker had gained 2 metres on his opponents. Needless to say a goal was scored.

Games

There were 16 games in total throughout this tournament, of which the last 4 were finals. In total there were also 9 referee teams from around the world. I was lucky or fortunate to officiate in 3 games throughout this time. My games were as follows:

Date

Venue

         

Crowd

20/06/03

St. Etienne

Japan

1

vs.

France

2

45,000

23/06/03

Lyon

USA

0

vs.

Cameroon

0

20,000

28/06/03

St. Etienne

Columbia

1

vs.

Turkey

2

26,000

At the end of the first round we were all taken out to the LIDO (cabaret show) were we celebrated in fine spirit. At the end of the night we were all called back to a meeting room where we were to find out which referees were to leave and stay. This was a happy but also sad evening. They read out the names and our team was staying. At that point the FIFA travel representative walked in and handed out the travel tickets to those 12 people who were leaving the very next day. In fact not only did we stay but we also ended up officiating in the Bronze medal play off for the tournament. What an honour!

Daily Schedule

Whilst the tournament was in full swing our days were fairly structured. Here is an example of a typical day give or take some variation:

Time Event
Usually 7.30am–9.00am
9.00am–11.00am
12.30pm–1.30pm
Breakfast
Training held at the institute of Paris
Lunch
Either 3.00pm –5.00pm Technical Review Meetings for those referees staying in Paris
Or 3.00pm –6.00pm Travel to venues for some officials – Lyon & St. Etienne
Either 6.30pm
11.30pm
If game day a bus to main venue was provided
Dinner
Or 6.30pm Dinner or Free Time or Organised Event
Apart from the Football aspect of the tournament we were all also very fortunate in that FIFA organised a number of tourist events for all officials, volunteers and support staff to attend. These were: a Seine river cruise starting at the Eiffel Tower, a Sight Seeing bus tour of Paris, the Lido Cabaret and Climbing the Eiffel Tower.
FIFA Official Logo
FIFA Official Logo
The Notion of Family / Teamwork at FIFA
To live, eat, work and breath FIFA throughout this tournament was a given. It was expected that we all ate, trained, attended meetings and functions together. Being a referee is not an easy thing to do. Adversity is built into the nature of what we do. The expectation was that you would support your colleague. In order to build this notion of family and teamwork FIFA started this from the very beginning. When we were given our equipment, we were told what to wear at training that is which colours. We were given the same suit, which was to be used for formal occasions, travel to and from grounds or venues and any other occasions where we represented FIFA.
It was obvious from the beginning good performances reflected well on all of us not just the team involved and likewise a bad performance. As we got to know referees from other countries we would wish them well as they departed for their game. Discussion and debate was encouraged in out technical review meetings, however, once agreement was reached we were all expected to follow the instruction or outcome.

Technology / Refereeing Teams

For this tournament FIFA was trailing a number of things. We were placed in a team so that the issue of communication and understanding would be a given. I have worked with the referee on many occasions and as a result I had a very good understanding of what was expected. We were also wired up to Radio Frequency Technology, that is, we all had an earpiece, microphone and transmitter. This allowed us to talk and pass on information to each other whilst the game was in progress. For assistant referees we also had electronic beepers in our flags. When we gave a decision we were able to press the decision and the referee would respond accordingly as he had a pack on his upper arm that would beep loudly.

Finally, in our last game (the Bronze Medal play off) we were also given heart rate monitors and pedometers in order to track my heart rate and distance travelled throughout the game. My resting heart rate was around 60 and throughout the game it got to 187. I roughly ran at 75% of my maximum for 90 minutes. For distance travelled as an approximate I also found out that on the line (a 55 metre distance) I ran between 6 to 8 kilometres. Some interesting statistics when you examine the issue of fitness, concentration and fatigue.

Many thanks to Jim Ouliaris for this excellent insight into the life of a FIFA Assistant Referee. (Web Master)

 


2. Relax. It is OK to hate Referees after all. They really are superior!

Take me back to the top of this page

The field of play resembles a mud bath, there are smudges of doggies doodoos as far as the eye can see. The lines are only visible if the sun is shining in the right direction. There is an odour of last night's takeaway pervading the air. The Alsatian dog in the centre circle is frothing at the moth when out come the 22 players with traces of this morning's fry-up on their chins, the reek of last night's beer on their breath and a look of murder in their eyes.

Our Ref. is already waiting for them in his pristine uniform. Boots polished, not a hair out of place, brilliant white topped socks. Our Ref. is a pillar of society, who is determined to do something, to put something back into society. Our Ref. is a model for all humans to emulate. He looks as though he was standing in the middle of Wembley. 

In his dreams he probably is.  And is he worried? Not a jot!

The result of a recent study of football Referees was revealed on 14 March 2003, showing that they are the toughest people on the pitch. A psychological profile carried out by university researchers Dr. Nick Neave and leading sports psychologist Dr. Sandy Wolfson from Northumbria University showed that Referees - not the players - are cool, confident, and have nerves of steel. Some 42 Senior Level Referees outside of the Premiership replied to forms filled in immediately before and after games. The average age of the Referees was 40, and they had spent on average of 12 years as a Referee. The oldest had been in the game for twenty-five years, the newest four years.

Dr Nick Neave, from Northumbria University said, "Only the strongest characters could survive the immense stresses of refereeing."

"They are a very strong, robust, confident set of people who have developed a very strong set of coping mechanisms. In psychological terms, they are very tough people.

They did not get nervous before games, were not concerned about sending players off or awarding penalties, and took abuse in their stride. While not immune to criticism, they seldom acknowledged being in the wrong."

Dr Nick Neave found that Referees share similarities with policemen, military men and hard-nosed politicians.

The research also discovered that a football Referee jogs about 10 kilometres in an average game - 47 % of that time was spent jogging, and18% running backwards. Referees were asked whether an improved fitness level would improve their officiating, but surprisingly, only 46% agreed with this.

The average time spent in Refereeing activities was 16 hours per week. This included travelling, attending meetings, officiating, writing match reports etc. Fifty percent agreed that this conflicted with their job, and thirty-eight percent said that it conflicted with their family commitments. But every one of them thought the time spent refereeing was worthwhile. This total dedication to the game, and the commitment of Referees was a strong theme running throughout the research.

The biggest surprise came when the referees were asked about their reaction to abuse.

Dr Neave added: "Referees get punched, kicked, even shot to death by players, coaches, owners and fans. But they regarded abuse as being very, very low stress, which we hadn't expected. They rarely felt stressed by their duties, though many did admit to experiencing occasional 'bad games' and being the constant target for dissent."

The research shows that Referees are ultra-confident, unflappable and totally confident in their own ability when confronted by the regular abuse hurled at them by infuriated parents, mangers spectators and players. Their honesty and commitment is on a level way above anyone else's. They suffer, apparently, from "illusory superiority".

"Illusory superiority denotes an odd group of people," said Dr Nick Neave. "Most people show it to some extent, but all Referees do. It is the sort of thing you would expect to find in traffic wardens and politicians."

These traits are not something that Senior Referees are born with, it comes of coping with years an years of torment that they have gone through to get there. They have had to work their way up from Sunday football, not only in managing 22 murderous players on the field of play, but also becoming more and more involved in policing difficult situations occurring outside of the game play itself.

"They tend to externalise everything," said Dr Neave. "They put any hostility down to people not understanding the laws, or being biased, rather than blaming themselves...

And each considered he was superior to other Referees. If they didn't have that confidence they would wilt," said Dr Neave." Their characteristics may be anti-social but they are necessary... to do their job properly."

So by concentrating on the players' emotional outbursts and the supporters' ignorance of the Laws of the Game, Referees are able to deal with the "constant negative feedback from external sources" and incessant abuse from the crowd.

Research source http://psychology.unn.ac.uk/nick/referees/index.htm
'Football Referees’ Self-perceptions and Coping Mechanisms': Dr Nick Neave and Sandy Wolfson Division of Psychology Northumbria University Newcastle-upon-Tyne


3. Collars and Cuffs (and all things white!)    by Julian Carosi   Take me back to the top of this page

I need to get this off my chest. In fact I need to get this of my chest, my collar, my wrists and the top of my shins.

Does anyone know who was responsible for introducing those annoying little white bits that Referees have on their kit? If you do, please let me know 'cause I want to nominate him for chief Referees' Supplies Officer - "Chief RSO" for short! ;-) Being a Referee, you'll need to stop and think a little bit about that one!

'R' 'S' 'O' Get it? - Oh well, never mind, let's move on………….

It wasn't that long ago, that Referees had to wear a blazer when officiating, but at least they never had the worry of 'the dreaded white bits!'

OK - so you get onto the park, and scout around for the inevitable hidden Assessor. Why is he inevitable? He is inevitable on this particular day, because last week you officiated in the confines of a mud bath that merged those preciously white bits of yours into a colour that could be registered as the 'first of its kind' in the Guinness Book of World Records. As it is your promotion year, you spent the best part of last Saturday night, dipping those lower white bits 'in-and-out of the sink' …'in-and-out of the sink' ….. 'in-and-out of the sink'….. to no avail. You'd think that in this 'day and age', somebody could invent a material that mud would NOT take kindly to. But no - they make the tops of Referees' socks out of some sort of cloth that has a unique magnetic mud collection property. Hey! ….what about a disposable sock-top - now there's a thought!

It wouldn't be so bad, if the 'missus' stopped her continuous moaning about the plug 'ole being blocked with grass!

So there he is, trying to look inconspicuous by hiding behind the only tree for miles. Mr Assessor….Bless his little cotton socks (I bet they don't have white bits on.) Now it's time to get your mind into gear, and try and put on a good show for Mr Assessor.

But wait!! ……………………

Why are you fretting?

You're fretting because instead of concentrating on the more important aspects of your game like Law interpretation and positioning, you can't get rid of that embarrassed redness about your face, due to that overriding niggle that just won't get out of your mind.

Instead of white stocking tops, you have 'not-so' white stocking tops. In fact, 'white' does not even come into the equation, else it would violate the Trades' Description Act. So instead of fulfilling that perfect performance that you have always dreamed about, you spend 90 minutes in purgatory, cursing the 'tightness of fist' that is a common trait of all Referees. Wouldn't it have been much much better, to have purchased TWO pairs of socks at the beginning of the season instead of the usual one? At least that way, you get to put the clean pair on at half-time, in the hope that the Assessor's eye sight in the first half is (metaphorically speaking) as bad as yours.

(Did you notice how I threw in that strange official Law 4 word 'stocking' at the top of the above paragraph. They always look nicer in black don't they boys?- But I'm transgressing ;-)

Back to the game……. would you believe it? What luck! In the changing room at half-time is the Referee from pitch No. 2. He must be having a bad game, 'cause he looks as white as a ghost. But as luck would have it, he has a new spare pair in his kit bag. In view of your desperation, you accept his 200% mark-up, and hand over a '£tenner' without so much as the slightest tightening of your fist!

So the game ends, and you go home in anticipation of the Assessor's damning Report on your performance (and more importantly - on your appearance). You wait a few weeks and no report arrives. A few more weeks go by, before it dawns on you that perhaps the man behind the tree was NOT an Assessor!! ……………CORRECT.

But the most annoying thing about this, is that you now have two pairs of the 'bloody useless' and whiter-less things in your kit bag.

But wait a minute - THERE WAS NO GAME ON PITCH NO. 2 THAT DAY!!

You had found him after all these years…….. CHIEF RSO

No wonder he was as white as a ghost!

Do any of you know have any tips for white bootlaces. But that's another story ……………………

Julian Carosi  www.corshamref.net   (Sept 2003)


 

4. Ref. is given his cards by the boss. (Story by Julian Carosi)

Take me back to the top of this page

Wayne Millin, of Nailsworth, Gloucestershire, and a member of the Stroud Referees' Society, created a buzz on T.V. channels, radio talk sport, five live, 'The Sun' national newspaper (22 Sept) and in all the local papers following his match on 28th of April 2003, Kings Stanley v Ebley in the Stroud & District football league.

Wayne's boss Robert Smith, just happened to be the manager of the Kings Stanley football team. During the first half of the game, as tempers were beginning to fray, Wayne, 35, claimed that his boss shouted:

"You’re a wa*ker ref ", from the touchline.

Wayne said: "I should never have been sacked!!!
Red carded ... Wayne Millin

When the ball next went out of play, Wayne approached his boss and told him he would be reported to the Gloucestershire Football Association (GFA). The situation was further exasperated in the bar after the game, where a player and work-mate of Wayne’s repeated the taunt, and was reported also.

At work the following day, Wayne's boss didn't believe him, when he was told that Wayne had indeed sent in the appropriate reports to the GFA. A month later, the boss duly received his report and fine. For the next two months Wayne was sent to Coventry, but not to Referee another match!. His boss and the rest of the staff gave him the cold shoulder, and refused to speak him to. Wayne sought legal advice, and on the 23rd of JUNE, handed in a solicitor’s letter about his treatment by the staff of JUST LABELS Ltd, asking for the bullying to stop.

On the 27th of June, Wayne went to work as normal - but when he got home, he found some reciprocal red cards of his own inside a letter saying that he had been made redundant from his £18,500-a-year job because of a fall in orders. But this was more likely to be due to the 'marching orders' Wayne had issued to his boss during the game!

Wayne said: "I should never have been sacked. I was just doing my job as a ref. It was only over a throw-in. But after I reported them I was totally ignored at work."

Wayne was advised by his Union (the G.P.M.U) that he had a good case for unfair dismissal. The tribunal was heard on the 19th September and was settled out of court, when Mr Smith agreed to give Wayne £6,000 in compensation. Mr Smith refused to comment further, saying: "It’s not worth the hassle."

Wayne told 'The Football Referee'.

"My ex-boss cannot be happy but he knows the Laws of the Game as he`s a ref. as well"


5. Reffing in Rockhampton                       Take me back to the top of this page

I live in Rockhampton Queensland Australia, a city of about 60,000 people with about the same number in satellite towns. Here in Aus we play in winter (April to September) as it is just too hot to consider in summer Temperatures then can top 45 degrees Celsius add a humidity factor of say 70-90 % & that can be quite unbearable. So winter it is but don't think that we pull out the overcoats, no while we may think it's cool at 20-36 degrees it's still damn hot to be running around especially in the early part of the season.


Heat is as you can imagine a major consideration around here & while FIFA say two equal halves of X minutes the instructions to our referees of junior games is "don't kill any one". If players are looking too stressed then pull the game short if you have to. I have stopped matches at a natural stoppage & ordered all players to leave the field & have a drink cool down & then return. A couple of minutes can make all the difference Admittedly it is not always possible to add on at the end of the game if there is another game waiting so "Them's the breaks". Surprisingly we've not had trouble with parents coaches or players for doing this, but then it is for the good of the players.
In seniors we play the regulated time for the match but may stop during a match for drinks, & I must admit that more than once I have been asked for a stoppage by players. This time is naturally added on.
Please don't think that we don't have a winter because it really will get cold at night & even I have been known to put on a long sleeved shirt for games.


We will always have those parents who know the rules better than us but sideline abuse in our junior matches has greatly decreased over the last few years with initiatives to encourage clubs to control their own fans, also the government has just started an advertising campaign to give the officials of all sports a fair go this seems to be having some impact throughout Australia & any improvement is to be applauded.
We in Rockhampton are blessed with some of the best refereeing role models you could hope for with Jaque Leleu FIFA assistant referee living here you don't tell her to get back in the kitchen! She has just returned from the Women's World Cup where she & the Australian team managed the 3-4 match. Also we have one of the national refereeing inspectors living here & they give a huge amount of their time to training our branch refs so the overall standard is quite high (except of course for me). Our state body Soccer Queensland encourages our young refs to travel about the state with an exchange programme which has proved a great success .


In a couple of weeks Soccer Australia Referees will cease to exist being replaced by the Australian Soccer Association & every thing will be changed throughout our game but for the better. So I can't say what we will be like next season other than we will move from strength to strength.
I hope that you find this informative
I am yours in soccer
Allan

By Allan Barber an ancient ref in Rockhampton, Queensland, Australia.
Many thanks to Allan for his insight in to refereeing in Australia.


6. Refereeing in Zimbabwe by Hilton Mukuwiri, Harare, Zimbabwe  Take me back to the top of this page

Hilton Mukuwiri, a 21 year old University student from Harare Zimbabwe tells 'The Football Referee' a little about the life and problems of being a new Referee in his country.

Every year, in each of the five provinces in our country, classes are held for new recruits where they are taught the Laws of the Game. After at least three months of tutorials, an exam is undertaken. It is rumoured that successful candidates are those who score above 75%. The exam questions are structured to allow the candidates to write down their own answers. These exams are usually taken in August. It then takes another six months before the results are released. However, following the decentralisation of the marking process, it has been announced that effort is being made to speed up the delivery to ensure that the results come back earlier,

Each year, all Referees are physically tested using the 'Cooper test'. The main hurdle being that one runs a minimum of 2700m in 12 minutes. Having successfully gone through these two tests the recruit qualifies to handle Division 3 matches in their respective provinces.

The Classes (levels) available in ascending order are namely: 4, 3, 2, 1 ordinary, 1 ZIFA and 1 FIFA. Promotion from Class 4 to 3 is automatic after a year in service. However, promotion to other Classes (levels) is based on one's performance and success in the written promotion exams. It's quite a long road to the top! Currently I'm in Class 3 following my last year's automatic qualification. It's interesting to note that I have met fellow Referees who have served for more than 10 years in one Class.

Class 1 ZIFA and FIFA Panel classes, officiate in the National Premier League (NPSL). There are three Division 1 Leagues Countrywide viz Northern, Southern and Eastern leagues where Class 1 Referees officiate; Class 2's officiate in Division 2 matches. Class 3 & 4's handle Division 3 games.

We hold monthly meetings in our respective provinces where amongst other things; we have a short lecture and discuss match incidents and receive the current month's fixture schedule.

The main problems we have, is that the number of people living below the poverty line in Zimbabwe has increased to beyond 80%. In this economy, the smooth running of football in my country is also effected. This has been exacerbated by the current political and economic condition prevailing in the country. Thus the issue of unavailability of money and lack of proper sponsorship, is where most of the Referees' problems are centred on.

It's the wish of every referee to be properly dressed when officiating a match, but circumstances hinder this dream. The match fees charged are so low that one may not be able to acquire proper equipment. Understated are the match fees for referees, payable after officiating a match.

Class 1 (FIFA and ZIFA):
Z$ 10 000 (£7)

Class 1 (ordinary):
Z$ 7500 (£5.26p)

Class 2:
Z$ 5000 (£3.50)

Class 3 and 4:
Z$ 2500 (£1.75)

Z$ = Zimbabwe Dollar

1 United Kingdom Pound
= 1,341.56 Zimbabwe Dollars

The average weekly wage in Zimbabwe is 4,500Z$ (£3.35).


The Z$ figures sound huge in quantity, but in actual fact, they are absolutely nothing in monetary value. For instance, a loaf of bread costs a whopping $3000 (£2.10), and a ride in public transport for a distance less than 25km is $1000 (£0.70p), same as the price for a 300ml Coca-Cola bottle. A 2l bottle of cooking oil is sold at $20,000 (£14). So with such exorbitant prices, it will remain a dream that one will buy good refereeing equipment, more so for the class 3 and 4s. Thus it sounds a norm to see some referees in brown/reddish formerly black uniforms. However we do have a few role models in the refereeing fraternity who do manage to have the best of everything!

Referees are there to enforce the Laws of the Game. It is a pity that most stadiums in Zimbabwe are not up to standard as to meet the requirements of the Laws of the game. Since they are the only available resources one is left with no option, but let play continue. Imagine a dusty, bumpy, non-flat terrain in which there are no nets on the goal posts. Some of the fields are so remote that one may travel on foot a distance of more than 5km to these venues. Unfortunately, nothing can be done about this, for soccer has to move on in all areas.

In my opinion, if we could have at least the following things in our Association, I believe our standards would improve; a VCR, Television, and Computer to name but a few. Its unfortunate we have none of the above, depriving opportunity to watch any video footage during development courses.

I'm happy however, that apart from these 'let downs', all referees are so dedicated to their work, such that they always try to put up the best of their performance in every match that they are assigned to handle.

Take me back to the top of this page