The www.CorshamRef.org.uk Newsletter No 68 (March 2008)

1st March 2009 International newsletter covering Football (Soccer) Refereeing matters.

Welcome, with an International perspective.

Welcome to the 68th edition of The Corsham Referee monthly International Football/Soccer Referees' newsletter.

Greetings to everyone.  This edition is a little earlier than usual, and focuses on injuries.

There are over 1,000 referees of all levels from all over the world that subscribe to this newsletter. Your comments and contributions are always welcome.

Keep up the good Refereeing work wherever you are in the world; and my best wishes go to all of you. Editor Julian Carosi.


NEWSLETTER CONTRIBUTIONS SOUGHT:

Last month I asked you for a single sentence of advice when dealing with angry players. Sadly I only received a few  contributions which are listed below.

Last month I also asked you for any Referee jokes as my store of Ref jokes has finally run out. Sadly I only received a few new contributions which are listed below.

A referee desperately needs to go to the toilet during a match so when he blows for half time he runs straight off to the clubhouse. It is packed with players and officials from a previous match. The referee, becoming more desperate pushes his way to the bar and exclaims, I don't want a drink barman just direct me to the gents quickly please!"
Barman says "No problem Ref - out that door, up the stairs, along the corridor, second door on right, up the spiral staircase, first door on left......"
"Don't worry, I'll find it" says the ref becoming close to breaking point and scurries off through the crowded bar to relieve himself.
He cant find the toilet, not remembering all directions and is finding odd rooms but no WC. He is desperate now and finds a room with just a hole in the floor boards. With no one around he feels the only option is to 'drop his cargo' into the hole. He does so with seconds to spare.
On descending back to the bar area ready to re-enter the field of play he notices the bar is empty except for the barman. "This place was heaving a minute ago" the ref says to the barman.
Barman then chirps up "Where the hell were you when the s**t hit the fan !?!"

Referee leaving the pitch at the end of the game is approached by the losing home team manager who says. "Well done ref, we have only had two bad referees all season, and you've just been both of them".


''SET PIECES' 
More 'set-piece' advice by Julian Carosi.

In my previous newsletters, I reiterated how a game of football/soccer consists of many - what can best be described as 'set-pieces', or jigsaw puzzle pieces that add up to form the whole 90 minutes. Each 'set-piece', if successfully managed, will result in the Referee maintaining control. One of the first aims of every Referee should be to use 'best-practice' techniques when managing 'set-pieces'. Once the standard 'set-piece' techniques have been mastered, the players' confidence in the Referee will increase, and they will more readily accept those awkward (non-set-piece) match-changing decisions, which seem to crop up in nearly every game. Subsequently, the Referee will feel more confident in the knowledge that at least he has a structured way to deal with the majority of situations that can occur in a game of football. 

In the article below, we add to the previous set-piece ideas on (1) how to manage throw-ins, (2) how to issue cards, (3) how to manage goal kicks, (4) how to build a positive image, (5) how to establish a rapport with players by gaining their trust via the TRUST triangle, (6) how to deal with simulation, (7) how to manage a penalty kick, (8) how to approach the kick-off at the beginning of each game, (9) how to manage the first 10 minutes of each game, (10) self-evaluation, (11) how best to apply advantage, (12) Assistant Referee tips, (13) using the Give and Go, Give and Sort technique during Free Kicks, (14) advice on Dealing with a Mass Confrontation Melee of players, (15) giving a standard Pre-Match brief to your Assistant Referees, (16) ideas on what to do at the Final Whistle, by (17) showing you How to Deal with Injuries via the S.E.R.I.O.U.S. Method.

These ideas are not prescriptive; rather, they will hopefully give you some new things to think about, and encourage you towards adopting a consistent approach by dovetailing them into your own style of refereeing to improve your performance.

S.E.R.I.O.U.S. method for dealing with Injuries.

Introduction: 

The Powers and Duties of the Referee listed in Law 5, state that the Referee is responsible, and has a duty to stop the match if, in his opinion, a player is seriously injured and ensures that he is removed from the field of play. An injured player may only return to the field of play after the match has restarted. 

The Referee can also allow play to continue until the ball is out of play if a player is, in his opinion, only slightly injured. It is the Referee's duty to ensure that any player bleeding from a wound leaves the field of play (immediately). The player may only return on receiving a signal from the Referee, who must be satisfied that the bleeding has stopped.

Dealing with injuries is the most important duty that a Referee has to perform when he controls a game of football. One performance area surprisingly deficient in many football/soccer Referees' capabilities, is that they do not have a standard process for dealing with injury situations on the field of play. If you can show the players that you sincerely care for their well-being, they will appreciate it, and they will respect you for it. 

The advice given here, is not just about how you can recognise injuries or how you should take a more considered approach when players are young children etc, it's also about encouraging you to have a set process that enables you to manage all injuries properly; whilst at the same time, keeping a watchful eye on the rest of the players. The latter is something that many Referees often forget to do when an injury occurs. 

Invariably, the Referee (in good faith) deals with each situation with the health and safety of the injured player paramount. But very often, there is little (or no) thought given, to proactively preventing eager trainers from rushing onto the field of play when there is no need to. Sensible close positioning by the Referee (whilst monitoring the injury situation) is also another consideration. The Referee has a duty to monitor all of the players, and not just the one who is injured. Another worrying aspect is the habit that some Referees adopt, of wandering away from the injury location, to have friendly conversations with the other players whilst the injury is being dealt with. Without a set injury process to use, it is also not surprising, that on other occasions, the Referee also forgets to ask the treated player to leave the field of play, and to await a signal to re-enter at a suitable time after play has been restarted. 

Having a process for managing injuries properly is not something that Referees are often taught or even consider. If you can do this right, then you have fulfilled your part, both as a caring human being who has a duty of care towards others, and as a Referee who has the added responsibility of trying to keep the game flowing whenever it is safe to do so.

The advice shown here encourages Referees to use a set process for managing injuries, it is a basis for improving the process that YOU use when dealing with injury situations. Also included below, is a selection of relevant useful injury information included in official publications. It is not surprising to see, that the Law book contains many references to injuries. But what is surprising is that many Referees have forgotten its importance. 

CONTENTS:

Part A: The S.ER.I.O.U.S. (Standard process for dealing with injuries in the field of play.)
Part B: Details contained within the Laws and other official publications concerning the safety of players and how to deal with injuries.
Note: Part B is too large for this newsletter. The whole article including Part B can be found on the web page below:
http://corshamref.org.uk/setpieces/setpieceinjuries.htm


Part A: The S.ER.I.O.U.S. (a standard process for dealing with injuries in the field of play.)

1. Serious? (The first consideration is to decide if an injury is serious or not.)
2. Evaluate? (Evaluate each injury situation as it arises. Does play need to be stopped?)
3. Race. (Sprinting to the scene of the injury).
4. Inspect. (Taking up a position that allows inspection of the injury and monitoring the remaining players).
5. Organise. (Taking charge, positioning and seeking medical assistance if it is required). 
6. Usher. (Overseeing the safe removal of injured players). 
7. Start. (Starting the game again after the injury has been seen to).


1. SERIOUS? (The first consideration is to decide if an injury is serious or not.)

If the injury is serious:

What is serious injury? 

In an emergency do not get distracted from the essential matters. On arriving at the scene, assess the situation, take in quickly what has happened, look for dangers to yourself and to the injured player, make the area safe, an unconscious player always takes priority and needs immediate help to make sure they can breathe, only then should any other injuries be assessed.

The A.B.C. priorities of First Aid when a player gets an injury are as follows 

A AIRWAY 
B BREATHING 
C CIRCULATION (and bleeding) 
Followed by burns and broken bones. 

Some examples of serious injury that can occur to a player in a game of football/soccer are:

Why is a head injury so serious?

A serious head injury may include some of the following symptoms: 

Immediately after a head injury occurs, it can be difficult to tell the difference between a mild concussion and a more serious injury. A brain bruise (contusion) or bleeding within the skull at first may cause only mild symptoms. 

Players who have experienced a head injury should be watched carefully for 24 hours. 

If serious head injury is suspected, an immediate visit to the hospital or to a Doctor is essential. Players who have suffered from concussion should be advised not to play any further part in the game.

When a non-serious injury occurs very near to a boundary line, and the injured player is capable of leaving the field, you should encourage him to do so. This will: (a) minimised the time lost (i.e. delayed restarts), and (b) prevent the trainer from crossing over the field to reach the scene. If you can remove the player safely, and then signal for the trainer to skirt the boundaries, to apply treatment off the field, it will enable you to restart the game much quicker.

What is concussion?

CONCUSSION is an internal head injury. Of all the head injuries, this is the most insidious, and many casualties have succumbed several hours after the incident. 

You should be especially observant when contact involves children - the myth that you can 'run off' concussion by 'playing on', is a dangerous attitude, and has caused grief and embarrassment to many players, parents and coaches when the player eventually collapses. 

Whether or not a player who has suffered possible concussion is fit to return after receiving treatment, should be deferred to the Club's medical staff. In the absence of such a person, the Referee has the authority under Law 5 to determine if a player is still seriously injured and, if necessary, to stop play and to require that the player is once again removed from the field of play. Concussion is a serious injury that must be taken SERIOUSLY. 

Concussion is potentially very serious, and an indifferent attitude is to be discouraged.

What are the signs and symptoms of fractured bones?


Some, or all, of the following:

Are damaged ligaments more serious than a broken bone? 

Bones are connected to each other in joints by ligaments. When excessive force is applied to joint, ligaments may be torn or damaged. This type of injury is a sprain. 

The seriousness of a sprain depends on how badly ligaments are damaged. Sprains can occur in any joint, but they occur most commonly in the ankle, knee, and finger.

Should the Referee allow a dirty sponge or dirty bucket of water to be used?


2. EVALUATE? (Evaluate each injury situation as it arises. Does play need to be stopped?)

You will need to quickly evaluate each injury situation as it arises. Initial evaluation can sometimes be done from a distance, but on other occasions, you will need to evaluate the seriousness of an injury from close quarters. Whether to stop play or not, depends on a number of factors which will need to be taken into consideration. Some of these are listed below:

If the player is only slightly injured.


3. RACE. (Sprinting to the scene of the injury).


4. INSPECT. (Taking up a position that allows inspection of the injury and monitoring the remaining players).

Inspecting and assessing the injury:


5. ORGANISE. (Taking charge, positioning and seeking medical assistance if it is required).


6. USHER. (Overseeing the safe removal of injured players). 


7. START. (Starting the game again after the injury has been seen to).

Summary:
There is a lot of information to consider in this S.E.R.I.O.U.S injury advice, but the words immediately below, summarise what you need to do to manage an injury situation properly. It is a very easy process to adopt. Try it. 

To emphasise how important the proper management of injuries is, see Part B, for several useful excerpts from official publications regarding injuries. Read them, as it will remind you of your main duty - the safety of the players.
Note: Part B is too large for this newsletter. The whole article including Part B can be found on the web page below:

http://corshamref.org.uk/setpieces/setpieceinjuries.htm

Stay safe.

Julian Carosi www.CorshamRef.org.uk

Happy reffing.


THE REFEREE'S SURVIVAL GUIDE

A fantastic referee book written by Jeffrey Caminsky from the USA was featured in the 2007 April edition of The Corsham Referee newsletter, where you can get details of how to buy Jeff's book entitled 'The Referee's Survival Guide'. Can be bought from Amazon.com. The book comes highly recommend by me (Julian Carosi) and provides answers to many of your problems on the field of play. Clearly written and easy to understand. The Referee's Survival Guide explains many of the "what's, how's, who's and why's" of life on the soccer field, as well as many of the things for a referee to avoid.

Below is a monthly excerpt to whet your appetite for Jeff's brilliant book.

Accidents and Other Misadventures
As with any contact sport, injuries are an unfortunate part of soccer. Most common mishaps are minor, and players can usually resume playing after a few moments of recovery, often with no need to stop the game. Occasionally, however, a player's injuries go beyond a minor knock on the shin or muscle cramp. When this happens, you must be able to assess the situation and help take appropriate action, which will vary depending upon the nature and severity of the injury, and the ready availability of medical help.

Stopping the Play
The Laws instruct us to let play continue despite minor injuries. When it looks like a player is seriously hurt, though, the game must stop before anyone can tell how severe the injury is, and decide what kind of treatment is called for.
While whistling to stop play for an injury is not forbidden, if you do so the restart will be a dropped ball. Complications arise if players do not know traditional soccer etiquette. The customary procedure is for the players to send the ball across a boundary line to tend to a player who needs help. If players are bringing an injury to your attention, you should direct them to kick the ball over the touch line. Note the time of the stoppage, and the appropriate restart. This may prevent embarrassment in the event that the stoppage is a lengthy one and everybody forgets how play - came to be stopped. It will also help you describe the incident on your match report. As with other noteworthy incidents, significant injuries need to be reported not only to advise the league of the event, but also to help document the injury in case of an insurance claim.
It is considered good sportsmanship for the team entitled to the restart to return the ball to the team kicking it out of bounds. Reminding younger teams of the customary protocol will help educate them in proper on-field behaviour. Failing to return the ball is not, however, a violation of the rules. This is the main reason why putting the ball into touch after an injury is usually better than whistling play to a halt. It results in fewer problems if the teams do not understand the traditions of the game.

Help for an Inured Player
Once play is stopped, you should go to the player to make a quick assessment of the nature and severity of the injury-. If the injury needs treatment, you should summon help as soon as the seriousness of the injury is apparent. As the match official, your responsibility does not include providing medical treatment or first aid. You already have a Job on the field, and must monitor and control everyone in and around the area. Tending to an injured player is a job best left to team officials, or trained medical personnel.

Medical Emergencies
On rare occasions, a player or other person may collapse at the field or suffer a major trauma. If this kind of emergency crops up at one of your matches, you may need to suspend the match and wait for help to arrive. Seriously injured people should only be moved by trained medical professionals. You should do nothing to jeopardize the safety of anyone in serious need of medical treatment, even if it means suspending or abandoning your match.
If the emergency arises nearby-, but not on the field where your game is being played, you should use your own common sense in deciding when and whether to continue your own match. The needs of a game will never match the life-and-death needs of a real medical crisis.

Many thanks to Jeffrey Caminsky for giving his permission for this article to appear.


SOCCERPEDIA

(A monthly extract from the brilliant book 'Soccerpedia' by my friend Andrew Ward. Arranged in A to Z format, this entertaining and authoritative book offers the chance to get to know the Laws of the Game and its history in detail.  Publisher Robson . Publication Date 28 September 2006: ISBN 1861059833 
Size (h x w) 234x156mm Pages 368  Normal price  £10.99 (approx. $20.35) Can be bought from Amazon.com

STOPPAGE-TIME

Referees have the power to add time to the end of each half to allow for time wasted, or lost, through accident or other reason (IFAB 1906). Stoppage-time includes time lost for injuries, substitutions, cautions, sendings-off, strategic time-wasting and temporary suspensions of play.
The first half of a cup tie at Bristol City lasted slightly under 67 minutes when an injury to Lloyd Owusu (Brentford) caused a long delay while an ambulance came to the side of the pitch (August 2000). A sending-off and a number of injuries led to eight minutes of stoppage-time at the end of the first half of a USA-El Salvador international (September 2004). The second half of Liverpool-Chelsea had six minutes of stoppage-time for six substitutions and two pitch invasions by lone spectators (May 2005). The first half of Grimsby Town-Derby County was extended by about fifteen minutes after a delay caused by a serious head injury to Grimsby's Steve Livingstone (August 2002). And Barton Rovers versus Chatham Town was suspended for 45 minutes while an ambulance arrived to deal with a head injury to Barnes (Barton) in September 2005.
Stoppage-time can be a tense, controversial period with a disproportionate amount of goals. Manchester United featured in two sensational periods of stoppage-time in the 1990s. They scored in the sixth minute of added-time against Sheffield Wednesday (April 1993), and twice in two minutes of stoppage-time to beat Bayern Munich in the 1999 Champions League Final.
In the 1994 FA Vase Final, Taunton Town lead Diss Town 1-0 until nearly ten minutes of stoppage-time had been played. Then goalkeeper Kevin Maloy (Taunton) was adjudged to have fouled Stephen Miles (Diss), and Paul Gibbs scored from the penalty. Cramp and minor injuries on a wet surface accounted for so much stoppage-time. Diss won 2-1 after extra-time.
A Leicester-Arsenal match caused controversy when Leicester equalised during a lengthy period of stoppage-time (August 1997). Conversely, the Blackburn-Leeds match seemed to halt suddenly when spectators expected lengthy stoppage-time after an eventful match (September 1997). Eventually, after experiment, the major British leagues adopted an Italian system whereby the fourth official holds up a board showing the minimum number of minutes the referee would add on. However, the match referee is the person in charge of the full-time whistle. In local football, there are tales of club officials, deputising for an absent neutral referee, adding on twenty minutes of stoppage-time while their team equalises.
Time is not added on for that lost in organising restarts (providing there is no unnatural delay). An assistant referee can aid a referee by signalling when the half's 45 minutes are used up (usually by holding the free hand across the chest). Time can be added on for a penalty-kick to be taken, but there needs to be a definite outcome (as explained in the penalty-kick section).
Calculating stoppage-time is more of an art than a science. Referees use various methods. Some stop their watch and restart it when the interruption ends; others point out that this is a risky method if you forget to restart the watch. Most keep a separate watch for stoppage-time. Others keep the stoppage-time in their heads, using a rough-and-ready method (thirty seconds for a caution, etc.). And one eccentric referee, believing that he only got paid for ninety minutes, carried a watch with no stop.

Many thanks to Andrew Ward for giving permission for his material to appear in this newsletter.


NEWSLETTER FEATURE:

Regular articles by Stanley Lover can be found on the www.CorshamRef.org.uk web site along with any respective images. 

A parody

Football Weapons of Mass Destruction by Stanley Lover

From our Front Line Football War Correspondent 
Over-flying spy cameras have caught the atrocities on film with close-up evidence of collateral damage to jaws, eyes and teeth

Elbows are the current Football Weapons of Mass Destruction (FWMD). I've witnessed many horrific atrocities committed by elbow FWMD in the name of victory at all costs. 

On every football battlefield two armies of warriors, each equipped with 22 of these deadly ready-for-immediate-launch missiles, engage in hostilities in the guise of a sporting contest - for the glories of victory, fame and fortune. Each army holds a reserve of potential FWMD in dugouts ranged along the borders of disputed territory.

Football police inspectors (match officials) know of their existence but their task of detection is made impossible when the lethal weapons are secreted under long sleeves or, when exposed, are cleverly camouflaged to appear as normal arms. How to detect the use of elbow FWMD occupies much time of war directors and football police but, effectively, the police are left on their own with their limited resources of human eyesight.

Elbow FWMD are most effective when arms are bent to a sharp bone crushing point and delivered to targets around the neck or face. They are employed in skirmishes disguised as legitimate attempts to claim possession of a prize object - a leather sphere.

Some cunning launchers time their strikes away from the prying eyes of the football police but, when spotted, they are signalled by a shrill blast of a whistle. Hostilities are stopped abruptly, and a temporary truce declared - to allow officers of the Medical Corps to enter the battleground and remove the dead and treat the wounded. In the meantime, the war police, confused by ham-acted claims of innocence by the assassin, are submerged in a mob of protesting fist-fighting troops. In the Official Observation Grandstand opposing Army generals and their political masters exchange verbal fire across gangway spaces. One side cries 'FOUL'; the other claims provocation and horror that their gentleman warrior should be so victimised.

But, over-flying spy cameras have caught the atrocity on film, with close-up evidence of collateral damage to jaws, teeth and eyes. Highly paid experts, seated in front of revealing screens, interpret the ugly scenes of mayhem and apportion blame. Often the football police are accused more severely - by cynical words of weakness and incompetence - than the culprits.

After the battle, filmed reports of the skirmish are examined, dissected, and debated in Fair Play committees by men of honour, dressed sometimes in UNO-blue suits. They pronounce judgements which may result in resting the guilty warrior from front line duty to reflect on his crime for a certain period. But, his elbows are not destroyed; his FWMD remain fused, to be used again when he returns, refreshed, into the next conflict.

The Rules of War (usually referred to as the Laws of the Game) are strict on correct battle-dress fashion for combatants in the front line. Rule/Law 4 pronounces thus:

'A player (combatant) must not use equipment or wear anything that is dangerous to himself or another player (combatant) - (including any kind of jewellery)

Forbidden items of jewellery e.g., rings or religious objects which scratch, tear and blind; necklaces, which choke and slice open blood- spouting jugular veins etc., must be controlled by football police. Obligatory self-protection includes shinguards, to reduce damage inflicted by reckless studs-up assaults. 
There is a simple solution to elbow FWMD, which protects both the launcher and the victim. On the principle of prevention is better than cure, elbow FWMD can be neutralized by requiring battling warriors to wear elbow pads. 

Apart from reducing calls for medical services, adding 'elbow pads' to Law 4 will ease the workload of Football War Crimes Commissions because, by removing the threat of elbow FWMD from arsenals of football battalions, embedded battle lawyers will have fewer cases to argue to hang assassins and jail incompetent football police. 

Elbow FWMD neutralizers are available - as one supplier claims - as 'high density, lightweight, low-profile foam protection for elbows, with cotton sleeves to give comfort, support, and flexibility'. 

Commercial neutralizers could be purchased for 15 to 20 US$ for two, in black or coloured, before the Great Bank Meltdown crisis of 2008. If cost is a deterrent safety and eco-conscious fair-players can improvise with pairs of old socks, cut-down, stretched over arms, and stuffed with cotton-wool over sharp-boned warheads. 

This proposal is tabled as just one measure to reduce casualties and reinforce the struggle for the hearts and minds of innocent football civilians - weary of violence in their favourite sport.


Yours in sport,
© Stanley Lover 2009


THIS MONTH'S QUESTION and ANSWER TOPICS:

Question 1: In a recent match an attacking player received a ball from his team mate and then scored a goal. The defending team were adamant that the attacker had deliberately handled the ball before he scored, the attacking team was adamant that he hadn’t. As the Referee, I didn’t see the offence and awarded the goal, but then the attacker immediately admitted that he did deliberately handle the ball before he scored the goal. What should I do?

Answer 1: These things do happen in football. If a player admits that he did handle the ball before he scored the goal, and you have not restarted play, then Law 5 allows you to change your decision.  In this case, if the attacker admits that he deliberately handled the ball, then restart play with a direct free kick to the defending team. Thank the perpetrator for his (eventual) honesty, and either give him a strong warning (not to do it again), or issue a caution if you really want to apply the Laws to the very extreme"!


Question 2: There used to be a ruling where if a referee realises during a match that a team has 12 players, the referee stops play and, weather/lighting permitting, re-starts the match in full. Any goals which may have been
scored will not count. As this ruling does no longer apply, I'd be grateful if you could let me know when this change of ruling occurred.

Answer 2: There never has been a ruling as such, as there are endless scenarios that can occur when an incorrect number of players occur. I have certainly never come across a ruling that asks Referees to start the match in full again, as that would be madness, and create all sorts of
problems. The advice in such situations has always been to simply dismiss the 12th player and report the facts. You are probably thinking about some of the vague old Law 4 FIFA Questions and Answers which last appeared in the Laws of the Game book for season 2006-2007.


Question 3: An incident has arisen in which some players have been wearing beanie hats or even in one case a hooded top to wear during a match as the weather is so cold. What are the restrictions as to player's clothing?

Answer 3: A player may use equipment other than the basic equipment provided that its sole purpose is to protect him physically and it poses no danger to him or any other player. 

Beanie hats are made of wool or soft material and pose no danger, but hooded tops do not fit into the criteria that a player's basic equipment must consist of separate items; therefore, my advice is that hooded tops (which also greatly restrict sight) should not be allowed. 

A Referee has some discretion to use common sense when making such decisions, so whatever you decide on, the players must comply. The age of the players, the weather conditions, whether the players are trying to dupe you, are just a few of many factors that you will need to consider.


Question 4: An Assistant Referee who is standing on the touchline 10 yards from the halfway line observes an attacking player standing in an offside position. 

The attacking team plays a forward pass, high over the defence towards the defending team's penalty area. 
Two attacking players chase the ball (one being the offside attacker and one coming from an onside position). 
The Assistant Referee follows them from his touchline position waiting to see if the onside player reaches it first. 
Just outside of the penalty area the offside player touches the ball before his teammate and the Assistant Referee correctly flags for the infringement.
Now the question is ....
Where is the free kick taken?
1) From the original place that the attacking player was in an offside position 10 yards inside the half?
or
2) From the place he became active just outside of the defending team's penalty area?
Some Level 4 colleagues are suggesting that you would crab 30 yards back up the touchline to indicate the original offside position and the kick would be taken from there. I have never seen this in practice and I have only seen Assistant Referees flag once the player becomes active and the free kick is taken in line with where they stop.

Answer 4: Offside is judged at the precise moment when the ball was originally played. Therefore, the indirect free kick should be taken from where the offside attacking player was (10 yards into the half) when the ball was originally played.

You were correct to run up the touchline to monitor play. As soon as the offside player becomes active, raise your flag, wait for the Referee to stop play, and when play has been stopped, run back up the touchline to the correct position, and lower your flag to indicate the correct offside location.


Question 5: If a Referee realises that Team A has scored a goal when they had an extra player on the field of play (who was interfering with play), the goal should be disallowed (so long as the Referee has not restarted with a kick off). So how should play be restarted correctly?

Answer 5: The goal is disallowed because the attacking team illegally had 12 players on the field of play. It makes no odds whether the illegal player interfered with play or not; the goal is still disallowed.
The last player to touch the ball was an attacking player.
The ball is no longer in play because it has travelled completely over the goal line.
Therefore the match should be restarted with a goal kick.


Question 6: If the sun is shining straight into an Assistant Referee's eyes, is he allowed to wear a hat?

Answer 6: There is nothing to stop an Assistant Referee from wearing a suitable hat so that he can shade his eyes when the sun is low and full in his face. A plain black baseball cap is the best option. 


Question 7: Recently in a match, I issued a red card (DOGSO) to a goalkeeper for deliberately picking up the ball just outside of his penalty area as an attacking player was in the process of trying to gain possession and strike the ball towards goal. Was I harsh in my decision? A senior referee friend of mine indicated that a goalkeeper should only be issued a caution in this case, and that in his many years of refereeing he has never seen and example of a goalkeeper being sent off for picking up or handling the ball outside of his penalty area. Can you please clarify?

Answer 7: The best way to understand this, is to imagine a player (not a goalkeeper) deliberately handling the ball just outside of his own penalty area, thereby denying an attacking opponent an obvious goal scoring opportunity. The outcome would be that you must send-off the defender in accordance with Law 12. When a goalkeeper comes out of his own penalty area, he loses his goalkeeper privileges, and in essence becomes a normal outfield player. The crux is therefore, not whether it was a goalkeeper or an outfield player, but whether the offence denied an obvious goal scoring opportunity or not, and in your case it did.
You were correct to send-off the goalkeeper - well done. It would be wrong to only issue a caution for the sending-off offence of 'denying an obvious goal scoring opportunity'.
The confusion arises, because when a goalkeeper deliberately handles the ball outside of his penalty area, in many cases he does not actually 'deny an obvious goal scoring opportunity', for example, the incident occurs to the side of the penalty area and the attacker is therefore not necessarily moving directly towards the goal, or two or more defenders are positioned so that they can prevent an obvious shot on goal. It is in these cases, that a caution for unsporting conduct can be justified.


I hope that you have enjoyed this issue of the newsletter, and that you are all continuing to enjoy your refereeing roles. 
All the very warmest wishes to you all, wherever you are in the world.

Regards, Julian Carosi (Editor)
www.CorshamRef.org.uk Newsletter Editor, Referee, FA Licensed Referee Instructor, FA Referees' Assessor and Mentor Wiltshire, England.
If you want to contact me, go to my website and select the Contact the Webmaster link under the cartoon on the home page or on the top left of the page.

Disclaimer: The content of this newsletter is not sanctioned by or affiliated with any governing body of soccer. The opinions expressed here are sometimes those of the Corsham Referee webmaster and the readers, or from other media sources. Reference to the male gender in this newsletter is for simplification only, and applies to both males and females. All rights of the current Laws mentioned in this newsletter are reserved by FIFA, and they are the official laws of the International Football Association Board. The Editor is not obliged to publicise unsolicited manuscripts or photos.

To subscribe or to unsubscribe to this newsletter, please go to the web site www.CorshamRef.org.uk